Lean migration: typeclass-based parameter passing, as in the Agda original

The port had flattened Agda's instance arguments ({{flA}}, {{evaluator}},
{{latticeInterpretation}}, {{validEvaluator}}) into explicitly threaded
values (fhL, E, I, hE). Restore them as typeclasses:

- Spa.FiniteHeightLattice: now actually used — Fixedpoint takes the
  instance instead of a FixedHeight value; FiniteMap gets the missing
  instance (height = ks.length * height B), so varsFixedHeight /
  statesFixedHeight / signFixedHeight / constFixedHeight plumbing
  disappears (instance bottoms are defeq to the old ones)
- Spa.Analysis.Forward.Evaluation: StmtEvaluator/ExprEvaluator become
  classes; the Valid* Props become Prop-classes, as in Agda
- Spa.Analysis.Forward.Adapters: the expr→stmt adapter and its validity
  are instances (Agda: the ExprToStmtAdapter instances)
- LatticeInterpretation is a class; sign/const interpretations,
  evaluators and validity proofs are instances; use sites read like the
  Agda module applications: result SignLattice prog

Proof simplifications (same theorems, proofs factored):

- Spa.Lattice.AboveBelow.monotone₂_of_strict: any ⊥-strict/⊤-dominated
  operation on a flat lattice is monotone — replaces the four near-
  identical case bashes per analysis (postulates in Agda)
- Spa.Lattice.AboveBelow.interp_sup_of/interp_inf_of: the shared flat-
  lattice interpretation case analysis, making interpSign_sup/inf and
  interpConst_sup/inf one-liners

lake build green with zero warnings; lake exe spa output verified
byte-identical (diff) to the previous, Agda-verified output.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
2026-06-09 23:32:38 -07:00
parent b26d6b5acd
commit b16f14fdfd
12 changed files with 338 additions and 407 deletions

View File

@@ -5,12 +5,13 @@ The Agda module instantiates `Lattice.FiniteMap` twice (variables ↦ abstract
values, states ↦ variable maps) and re-exports everything with ᵛ/ᵐ suffixes.
In Lean the two instantiations are `abbrev`s and the FiniteMap API is used
directly; the module parameters (the finite-height lattice `L`, the program)
become section variables.
become section variables, with the finite-height structure and the lattice
interpretation arriving by instance resolution as in Agda.
Correspondence:
VariableValues, StateVariables ↦ VariableValues, StateVariables
isLatticeᵛ/isLatticeᵐ, ⊔ᵛ, ≼ᵛ … ↦ (the FiniteMap Lattice instances)
fixedHeightᵛ ↦ varsFixedHeight
fixedHeightᵛ, fixedHeightᵐ ↦ (the FiniteMap FiniteHeightLattice instance)
⊥ᵛ, ⊥ᵛ-contains-bottoms ↦ botV, FiniteMap.bot_contains_bots
states-in-Map ↦ states_memKey
variablesAt ↦ variablesAt
@@ -39,22 +40,9 @@ abbrev VariableValues : Type := FiniteMap String L prog.vars
/-- Agda: `StateVariables`. -/
abbrev StateVariables : Type := FiniteMap prog.State (VariableValues L prog) prog.states
variable {h : }
/-- Agda: `fixedHeightᵛ`. -/
def varsFixedHeight (fhL : FixedHeight L h) :
FixedHeight (VariableValues L prog) (prog.vars.length * h) :=
FiniteMap.fixedHeight fhL prog.vars
/-- Agda: `⊥ᵛ`. -/
def botV (fhL : FixedHeight L h) : VariableValues L prog :=
(varsFixedHeight L prog fhL).bot
/-- Agda: `fixedHeight` on `StateVariables` (assembled in `Forward.agda`'s
fixpoint call; named here for reuse). -/
def statesFixedHeight (fhL : FixedHeight L h) :
FixedHeight (StateVariables L prog) (prog.states.length * (prog.vars.length * h)) :=
FiniteMap.fixedHeight (varsFixedHeight L prog fhL) prog.states
/-- Agda: `⊥ᵛ` (the bottom of `fixedHeightᵛ`, now found by instance search). -/
def botV [FiniteHeightLattice L] : VariableValues L prog :=
FiniteHeightLattice.bot (VariableValues L prog)
variable {L prog}
@@ -81,16 +69,16 @@ theorem variablesAt_le {sv₁ sv₂ : StateVariables L prog} (hle : sv₁ ≤ sv
FiniteMap.le_of_mem_mem prog.states_nodup hle
(variablesAt_mem s sv₁) (variablesAt_mem s sv₂)
variable (fhL : FixedHeight L h)
variable [FiniteHeightLattice L]
/-- Agda: `joinForKey`. -/
def joinForKey (k : prog.State) (sv : StateVariables L prog) :
VariableValues L prog :=
(sv.valuesAt (prog.incoming k)).foldr (· ·) (botV L prog fhL)
(sv.valuesAt (prog.incoming k)).foldr (· ·) (botV L prog)
/-- Agda: `joinForKey-Mono`. -/
theorem joinForKey_mono (k : prog.State) :
Monotone (joinForKey fhL k) := by
Monotone (joinForKey (L := L) k) := by
intro sv₁ sv₂ hle
exact foldr_mono _ (FiniteMap.valuesAt_le hle (prog.incoming k)) (le_refl _)
(fun b _ _ hab => sup_le_sup_right hab b)
@@ -98,40 +86,42 @@ theorem joinForKey_mono (k : prog.State) :
/-- Agda: `joinAll` (the "Exercise 4.26" generalized update with `f = id`). -/
def joinAll (sv : StateVariables L prog) : StateVariables L prog :=
FiniteMap.generalizedUpdate id (joinForKey fhL) prog.states sv
FiniteMap.generalizedUpdate id joinForKey prog.states sv
/-- Agda: `joinAll-Mono`. -/
theorem joinAll_mono : Monotone (joinAll (prog := prog) fhL) :=
FiniteMap.generalizedUpdate_monotone monotone_id (joinForKey_mono fhL)
theorem joinAll_mono : Monotone (joinAll (L := L) (prog := prog)) :=
FiniteMap.generalizedUpdate_monotone monotone_id joinForKey_mono
/-- Agda: `joinAll-k∈ks-≡`. -/
theorem joinAll_mem_eq {s : prog.State} {vs : VariableValues L prog}
{sv : StateVariables L prog} (h : (s, vs) joinAll fhL sv) :
vs = joinForKey fhL s sv :=
{sv : StateVariables L prog} (h : (s, vs) joinAll sv) :
vs = joinForKey s sv :=
FiniteMap.generalizedUpdate_mem_eq (prog.states_complete s) h
/-- Agda: `variablesAt-joinAll`. -/
theorem variablesAt_joinAll (s : prog.State) (sv : StateVariables L prog) :
variablesAt s (joinAll fhL sv) = joinForKey fhL s sv :=
joinAll_mem_eq fhL (variablesAt_mem s (joinAll fhL sv))
variablesAt s (joinAll sv) = joinForKey s sv :=
joinAll_mem_eq (variablesAt_mem s (joinAll sv))
/-! ### Lifting an interpretation to variable maps -/
variable (I : LatticeInterpretation L)
variable [I : LatticeInterpretation L]
omit [FiniteHeightLattice L] in
/-- Agda: `⟦_⟧ᵛ`. -/
def interpV (vs : VariableValues L prog) (ρ : Env) : Prop :=
(k : String) (l : L), (k, l) vs
(v : Value), Env.Mem (k, v) ρ I.interp l v
/-- Agda: `⟦⊥ᵛ⟧ᵛ∅`. -/
theorem interpV_botV_nil : interpV I (botV L prog fhL) [] := by
theorem interpV_botV_nil : interpV (botV L prog) [] := by
intro k l _ v hmem
cases hmem
omit [FiniteHeightLattice L] in
/-- Agda: `⟦⟧ᵛ-⊔ᵛ-`. -/
theorem interpV_sup {vs₁ vs₂ : VariableValues L prog} {ρ : Env}
(h : interpV I vs₁ ρ interpV I vs₂ ρ) : interpV I (vs₁ vs₂) ρ := by
(h : interpV vs₁ ρ interpV vs₂ ρ) : interpV (vs₁ vs₂) ρ := by
intro k l hmem v hv
obtain l₁, l₂, rfl, h₁, h₂ := FiniteMap.mem_sup hmem
rcases h with h | h
@@ -141,13 +131,13 @@ theorem interpV_sup {vs₁ vs₂ : VariableValues L prog} {ρ : Env}
/-- Agda: `⟦⟧ᵛ-foldr`. -/
theorem interpV_foldr {vs : VariableValues L prog}
{vss : List (VariableValues L prog)} {ρ : Env}
(hvs : interpV I vs ρ) (hmem : vs vss) :
interpV I (vss.foldr (· ·) (botV L prog fhL)) ρ := by
(hvs : interpV vs ρ) (hmem : vs vss) :
interpV (vss.foldr (· ·) (botV L prog)) ρ := by
induction vss with
| nil => cases hmem
| cons vs' vss' ih =>
rcases List.mem_cons.mp hmem with rfl | hmem'
· exact interpV_sup I (Or.inl hvs)
· exact interpV_sup I (Or.inr (ih hmem'))
· exact interpV_sup (Or.inl hvs)
· exact interpV_sup (Or.inr (ih hmem'))
end Spa